Recent news of threats to kill Donald Trump put me in mind of the case of Edward Oxford who attempted to shoot Queen Victoria. John Birt Davies played a key role in his Old Bailey trial when he appeared as an expert medical witness.
Shots ring out
On 10th June 1840, four months after their wedding, Queen Victoria and Prince Albert were travelling through Hyde Park in an open carriage waving at the crowds and enjoying the fresh air. The Queen was pregnant with her first baby. All of a sudden, their peace was disturbed by a young man who had been waiting for them with a pair of loaded pistols. He rushed forward to within three yards of the carriage, discharging both guns in a cloud of smoke. Luckily, both shots missed their target, and the Queen and Prince Albert were alarmed but unharmed.
The young man was seized by onlookers and quickly disarmed, all the while openly confessing to the crime. The police were called, he was arrested and charged with treason. Needless to say, this extraordinary event attracted huge coverage in the national press.
The would-be assassin was an unemployed eighteen-year-old ex-barman named Edward Oxford. He was living in Camberwell at the time of the crime, but he had been born and brought up in Birmingham. By a strange twist of fate, Birt Davies knew Oxford’s family, having been called to their home in 1824 to treat his father, who had poisoned himself with an overdose of laudanum. When Edward Oxford’s trial opened at the Old Bailey on 8th July numerous witnesses were called, including Birt Davies.
Oxford’s trial
Oxford’s defence focused on his allegedly unbalanced state of mind at the time of the offence. It was a common assumption that mental abnormalities could be inherited, so the court was keen to hear about Oxford’s family background.
Witnesses, including his mother, described a traumatic childhood with a violent father and a grandfather who had been placed in a straitjacket on account of his insanity. His father was frequently intoxicated, often threatening to kill himself, and he treated his wife with brutal violence in front of their seven children. Oxford senior died in 1829 when his son was aged just seven, but from a very young age Edward had displayed disturbed behaviour, often crying without apparent cause, falling into violent rages and threatening to beat up his siblings. He was said to be obsessed with firearms and gunpowder.
When Birt Davies was called to the witness stand, he was asked his opinion on the sanity or insanity of the prisoner. Birt Davies stated he believed Oxford to be insane, citing as evidence his abnormal reactions – he had made no attempt to conceal himself when apprehended, had spoken openly about the crime, and had no apparent motive for his attack on the Queen.
Further witnesses confirmed the view that he was of unsound mind. This opinion impressed the jury who, after deliberation, reached the verdict: ‘Not guilty, being insane. To be detained during Her Majesty’s pleasure.’
Required to serve an indeterminate period in a mental hospital, Oxford was committed to the Bethlem asylum in London where he spent several years, before being transferred to Broadmoor. When finally released after twenty-four years of incarceration, he went into exile in Australia, where he lived under an assumed name and died in Melbourne in 1900.
Queen Victoria, who was said to have been very dissatisfied with the not guilty verdict, survived eight assassination attempts during her long reign, of which this was the first. Her refusal to be cowed by these threats helped to earn her huge public respect. Will it be the same for Trump I wonder?
For more on this story and other cases, see my new book Probing Deaths, Saving Lives.